Skip to main content
Lasbury Tracy Realty Inc
← Back to search

$3,750,000

Active

1249 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota, FL 34231

4 beds · 4 baths · 5,814 sq ft

Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY · MLS# A4707252

Listed today

Refreshed from the Stellar MLS feed . This listing’s MLS record last changed .

About this home

Virtually Staged. Set within Oyster Bay, one of Sarasota’s most distinguished West of Trail neighborhoods, this exceptional waterfront estate enjoys a rare setting with captivating water views. Across the street, a picturesque neighborhood park and waterfront open space preserve beautiful views to the south, while the rear of the property looks north over a tranquil bayou with long vistas extending out to Sarasota Bay. Centered around the historic Field Club—originally the winter estate of the Marshall Field family—Oyster Bay is treasured for its graceful streets, mature tropical canopy and enduring sense of community. Its coveted location places residents moments from the shops and restaurants of Southside Village, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Siesta Key’s renowned beaches and the cultural attractions of downtown Sarasota. The main level in this estate-scale residence features three bedrooms and two-and-a-half baths, a fourth downstairs bedroom or office, formal dining room, generously proportioned living and family rooms, and a spacious kitchen, with water views enhancing many of the principal living spaces. The largest bedroom on the main level looks north to the pool area and Bay, serving as a second primary suite or a multigenerational retreat complete with a separate exterior entrance. An elevator and dramatic staircase lead to the second level, where a substantial media and game room with stunning views accompanies an extraordinary primary suite addition. Created as a private sanctuary, the suite opens to two balconies showcasing sweeping views toward the bay from both the north and south. Outside, the expansive pool and spa terrace provides an inviting backdrop for entertaining, relaxing and enjoying Sarasota’s year-round outdoor lifestyle. Direct access to the open waters of Sarasota Bay makes this property a boater’s delight. Ready for its next chapter, the home has a new roof completed in 2024 and presents a compelling opportunity for a new owner to customize, enhance and create an enduring family estate to be enjoyed for decades to come. With waterfront vistas at both the front and rear, an impressive 15,459 SF lot, exceptional interior space and a premier address in one of Sarasota’s most established bayfront communities, this Oyster Bay residence presents a truly rare opportunity.

Facts

Property type
Single Family Residence
Year built
1959
Bathrooms
3 full, 2 half
Living area
5,814 sqft
Lot size
0.35 acres
Waterfront
Yes · 94 ft
Water access
Bay/Harbor, Canal - Saltwater, Intracoastal Waterway
Water view
Yes
Private pool
Yes
Exposure
South
Furnished
Unfurnished
Flood zone
AE, VE
CDD
No
55+ community
No
Annual taxes
$17,104/yr
Monthly fees
$29/mo
Listed
Sep 18, 2026
MLS #
A4707252

Get an email when homes like this list

New Sarasota listings with at least 4 bedrooms up to $4,690,000. Free, and you can stop any time.

Estimate the monthly payment

Estimate by Lasbury Tracy Realty — not a loan offer

Starting figures for 1249 N LAKE SHORE DR. Everything below is editable.

AssumptionNot a quoted rate. Ask a lender what you actually qualify for today.

From this listingThe seller's most recent annual tax bill as reported to the MLS. Your bill will differ — Florida reassesses on sale and homestead caps reset.

Editable estimateA placeholder, not a quote. On the Gulf Coast this is the line item most likely to be wrong: premiums swing on roof age, wind mitigation, elevation, and carrier appetite. Get a real quote before you rely on this number.

Starts at $0Deliberately zero until you enter a figure — we will not inflate a payment with a guess. Many homes here need it; the flood zone and the current policy's premium decide the number.

From this listingMonthly association fee as reported to the MLS. Confirm what it includes, and ask about special assessments.

AssumptionNot applied — your down payment is 20% or more.

Estimated total monthly payment

$23,541

$18,962 of that is principal & interest. 19% is taxes, insurance and fees — which is why those inputs matter more here than the rate does.

Principal & interest
$18,962
Property taxes
$1,425
Homeowners insurance
$3,125
Flood insurance
$0
HOA / condo fees
$29
Mortgage insurance (PMI)
$0
Total per month
$23,541

Over the life of the loan

Loan amount
$3,000,000
Down payment
$750,000
Total interest
$3,826,335
Principal + interest paid
$6,826,335
Paid off in
2056

Interest is the exact schedule total for a fixed-rate loan held to term and assumes no extra payments. Taxes, insurance and fees are not included in these lifetime figures because they change every year.

Calculated on this page from the figures above — the calculator sends none of them anywhere, and no lender is quoting you. Only the separate flood & insurance request sends anything: what you type into it, to a Lasbury Tracy agent. Figures are estimates for planning only, not a pre-approval, commitment to lend, or a statement of the taxes and insurance you will actually be charged. Lasbury Tracy Realty Inc. is a real estate brokerage, not a lender or an insurance agent.

What did the most similar homes nearby actually sell for?

The closest recent sales to this home, with what they sold for and when.

Take a tour

Pick a day that suits you — a licensed Lasbury Tracy agent confirms personally, usually within minutes. No account needed.

1249 N Lake Shore Dr, Sarasota, FL 34231

Listing courtesy of MICHAEL SAUNDERS & COMPANY · MLS# A4707252 · Active

How would you like to see it?
Which day?
What time of day?

In person · Tue, Nov 17 · Morning (9-12)

No account, no obligation. Prefer to talk? (941) 474-5585

Where this home is

Opens on aerial — on this coast the canal, the lot and the neighbours answer more questions than a street grid does.

Similar homes

Listing information is provided in part by Stellar MLS, as distributed by MLS GRID. Based on information submitted to the MLS as of Nov 16, 2026, 8:46 PM (ET). All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or MLS. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Some IDX listings have been excluded from this website.

Lasbury Tracy Realty Inc. · [email protected]