Burnt Store Isles homes for sale
26 homes for sale in Burnt Store Isles, Punta Gorda. 21 lots for sale →
Living in Burnt Store Isles
This is Burnt Store Isles, the canal neighborhood on Punta Gorda's south side, which the MLS files mostly under its subdivision name, Punta Gorda Isles Section 15. It has its own city canal district: the City of Punta Gorda's Burnt Store Isles Canal Maintenance District looks after 18 miles of seawall, 9 miles of canals and the BSI boat lock, paid for by an assessment on the district's properties. Homes date from 1980 to new construction, nearly all single-family, and most sit on the water with a private pool.
- HOA / fees
- a few dollars a month or none on most listings — Seawalls and canal dredging are paid for by the Burnt Store Isles canal-district assessment, which City Council sets each year — separate from any association fee.
- Amenities
- City-maintained seawalls and canal dredging (Burnt Store Isles canal district) · BSI boat lock, maintained by the district · Private pools on most homes
- Know before you fall in love
- Some canal construction needs a Canal Construction Special Permit from the BSI Canal Advisory Committee or City Council before work starts — ask before planning a dock, lift or seawall change · Boaters: ask how the route from the dock runs through the lock to Charlotte Harbor, and what that means for your boat
- Flood story
- Every listing here that reports a FEMA zone reports AE: budget for flood insurance and ask for the elevation certificate.
Drafted from listing records and community sources; pending verification by Lasbury Tracy Realty. Spot an error? Tell us.
Burnt Store Isles by the numbers — current listings
$707,000
Median asking price
$195,000–$1,500,000
Current range
$0
Median monthly fees
54%
Homes with no fee
1983–2026
Built
96%
With private pool
54%
Waterfront
21
Buildable lots listed
























